News
5
minute read
Why Your Airbnb Is Occupied But Still Not Profitable
Written by Miles Udemezue, Commercial Director, Lettd.
Occupancy measures how busy a property is, not how much money it makes. A short let can run at 95% occupancy and still return less than a long-term tenancy, because occupancy tells you nothing about your nightly rate, your cost per booking, or how much of each payout the platform keeps.
There are four things that usually explain the gap between a full calendar and a disappointing payout: cleaning costing more than it should, pricing that does not move with demand, a listing that has no clear audience, and total dependence on booking platforms that take roughly 15% of everything.
Here is how to diagnose which one is affecting your property.
First, the proof that occupancy misleads
A four bedroom house in MK6 that Lettd manages ran at 97% occupancy in May 2026, at an average nightly rate of £134.16, and generated £4,024.90.
In July, occupancy was allowed to fall to 81%. The average nightly rate rose to £239.07. Revenue was £6,974.35.
Sixteen points of occupancy given up. Nearly £3,000 more revenue.
Part of that is seasonal, since July is peak in Milton Keynes. But the rest was a decision to stop accepting bookings at May rates during a period when the property could command far more. A calendar full at the wrong price is not an achievement.
If you are tracking one number, track revenue per available night: total revenue divided by every night the property was available, booked or not. In the example above it went from roughly £130 to roughly £225 while occupancy went backwards.
Cause 1: You are paying too much for cleaning
This is the most common and the easiest to fix.
Cleaning is the only major cost that scales with the number of bookings rather than with revenue. Every other cost is either fixed or a percentage. That makes it the line most likely to quietly eat a busy month.
Agency versus directly engaged cleaners. A one bedroom turnover in Milton Keynes costs us £20 to £35 with directly engaged cleaners, including linen washing. Agency rates carry a margin on top of the cleaner's pay, and on a property turning over nine or ten times a month that margin compounds into hundreds of pounds a year per unit.
On larger properties the gap is dramatic. A four bedroom turnover costs around £80 with in-house cleaners and owned linen, or up to £200 with an agency and hired linen. On six turnovers a month, that is a £720 difference. It moves the revenue a four bedroom property needs just to break even against a long-term tenancy from roughly £3,234 to roughly £4,169.
Same property. Same guests. Same occupancy. £900 a month of difference in how the turnover is resourced.
Your cleaning fee may be set below your cleaning cost. Check this today. Remember the platform takes its percentage of the cleaning fee as well as the accommodation fare, so a £35 cleaning fee returns roughly £30. If your actual turnover costs £45, every single booking loses £15 before anything else happens, and it is completely invisible inside a revenue figure that looks healthy.
Short stays multiply the problem. A one night booking and a four night booking incur exactly the same cleaning cost. Nine turnovers across a near full month implies average stays of three nights or more. The same property averaging one and two night bookings would run fifteen or more turnovers at identical occupancy, adding several hundred pounds of cleaning for no additional revenue. The occupancy figure would be unchanged.
What to do: work out your true cost per turnover including linen. Compare it to the cleaning fee on your listing, after the platform fee. Then look at your average length of stay, and consider whether a two or three night minimum would cost you less in lost bookings than it saves in turnovers.
Cause 2: Your pricing is not moving with demand
Flat pricing loses money in both directions. Too high in quiet weeks, so the property sits empty. Far too low in peak weeks, so it fills instantly at a rate that leaves money on the table.
That second failure is the one that produces high occupancy and low profit. A property priced flat will always look busiest during the periods when it is most underpriced.
Milton Keynes has demand patterns worth pricing against: contractor placement cycles, corporate booking lead times, the academic calendar around the Open University, hospital appointment patterns, and local events. Rates need to respond to all of it.
There is also a floor problem. Some Milton Keynes one bedroom listings are running at £50 a night. At that rate, after platform fees, management, cleaning and consumables, a one bedroom flat needs roughly 81% occupancy just to match what a long-term tenancy would net, before accounting for the extra work, the volatility and the faster wear. At £90 a night the same property breaks even at 45%.
Undercutting does not win. It moves a property into a position where it has to be nearly full all year to justify existing.
What to do: use dynamic pricing software rather than setting rates manually. Check whether your busiest weeks are also your cheapest, which is the signature of flat pricing. Stop treating a low nightly rate as a route to occupancy.
Cause 3: Your listing has no specific audience
Most underperforming listings are written for nobody in particular. Generic title, generic photos, description that could describe any flat in any town.
A guest scrolling a results page is looking for a reason to choose yours. "Lovely 2 Bed Apartment" gives them nothing. A contractor on a three week placement wants to know about parking, a desk, fast broadband and whether they can actually cook. A visitor attending Milton Keynes University Hospital wants to know how far away it is. Someone visiting the Open University wants to know about the campus.
Milton Keynes short let demand is corporate rather than touristic. It comes from contractors, medical and hospital visitors, Open University visitors, relocating professionals and families. A listing written for holidaymakers is competing for a segment that barely exists here.
The story has to be true, and it has to be reflected in the property. Telling contractors there is a workspace means there is an actual desk and chair, not a dining table.
Reviews are part of this. A property with few reviews converts badly regardless of how good the listing is, and no amount of description fixes it. For a new listing, pricing below steady state for the first bookings to build review volume quickly is worth doing deliberately, then stepping rates up.
What to do: decide who the property is for, then rewrite the title, the photographs and the description around that guest. If nothing about the property suits a specific audience, that is the thing to fix first.
Cause 4: Everything comes through the platforms
This is the largest single deduction on any short let, and the hardest to do anything about.
The platform fee is roughly 15% of the total, including the cleaning fee. On a one bedroom flat grossing £3,089 in a month, that is £463. On a four bedroom house grossing £6,974, it is over £1,000. Every pound of that is money the property earned and did not keep.
A direct booking carries no platform fee. Shift 30% of revenue to direct channels and a four bedroom property keeps roughly £300 a month it was previously handing over. Same guests, same nights, same occupancy, better margin.
That is the arithmetic, and it is why direct booking is the biggest lever available. But I want to be straight about two things.
It is slow. Direct bookings require a booking site, payment processing, visibility on Google's accommodation results, and above all a base of repeat guests who trust you enough to book outside a platform. That takes years, not months. Lettd's own direct share is currently small. We are building it, and I would not claim otherwise.
It is very hard to do alone. A landlord with one property has no realistic route to a direct channel. There is not enough booking volume to justify the infrastructure, and no repeat guest base to draw on. This is one of the genuine structural advantages of a managed portfolio: the direct channel is built once and serves every property in it.
A caution. Booking platforms prohibit diverting a guest off-platform during a booking. Building a direct channel means earning repeat business after a stay, and marketing to your own audience, not intercepting platform enquiries. Read the terms.
What to do: in the short term, make sure you are at least on more than one platform. Airbnb alone caps you, because contractors and corporate guests frequently book through Booking.com, often further in advance. Vrbo, a direct booking site and Google's accommodation results all reach segments the others do not. In the longer term, capture guest details lawfully and give repeat guests a reason to come back to you directly.
The diagnostic
Run these against your own property.
What does a turnover actually cost, including linen?
What cleaning fee is on your listing, and what does it return after the platform fee?
What is your average length of stay, and how many turnovers is that per month?
Are your busiest weeks also your cheapest weeks?
Who specifically is your listing written for?
How many booking channels are you on?
What percentage of your revenue came from direct bookings?
What is your revenue per available night, and is it moving?
If you cannot answer questions one, two and eight, that is the place to start. Most properties that are busy but unprofitable are losing the money in cleaning and pricing, and the owner cannot see it because occupancy looks fine.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my Airbnb fully booked but not making money? Usually one of four things: cleaning costing more per turnover than the cleaning fee recovers, flat pricing that fills the calendar cheapest during peak demand, a listing with no specific target guest, or complete reliance on booking platforms taking roughly 15% of every payout. Occupancy measures how busy a property is, not how profitable.
Is high occupancy good for an Airbnb? Not on its own. A four bedroom MK6 property Lettd manages generated £4,024.90 at 97% occupancy in May 2026 and £6,974.35 at 81% occupancy in July. Occupancy fell and revenue rose substantially. Revenue per available night is the more useful measure.
How much should an Airbnb cleaning fee be? At or above the actual cost of the turnover, allowing for the fact that the booking platform takes its percentage of the cleaning fee too. A £35 cleaning fee returns roughly £30 after a 15% platform fee. If the turnover costs more than that, every booking loses money.
Do short stays lose money on Airbnb? They can. A one night booking and a four night booking cost the same to clean. A property averaging one and two night stays runs far more turnovers than one averaging three or four nights at identical occupancy, adding cleaning cost without adding revenue. A two or three night minimum often nets more than an open calendar.
Are direct bookings worth it for Airbnb hosts? The platform fee is the single largest deduction on a short let, so avoiding it is the biggest available margin gain. On a property grossing £3,089 a month the platform takes roughly £463. However, building a direct channel requires a booking site, payment processing and a base of repeat guests, which takes years and is difficult for an owner with a single property.
Should I list on Booking.com as well as Airbnb? Usually yes. Contractors and corporate travellers frequently book through Booking.com, often further in advance, because that is what their expense process expects. Relying on Airbnb alone caps occupancy by limiting you to one guest segment.
Figures in this article come from Lettd's own managed portfolio in Milton Keynes and reflect a small number of properties over a limited period, including peak-season months. They are not representative of the Milton Keynes short let market as a whole. This article is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice.
